Reviewing is the New Advertising

It should come as no surprise that consumers trust reviews more than they trust advertising. But reviews themselves are becoming a form of advertising and based on results of the recent Nielsen Global Online Consumer Survey (pdf) it’s working:

“Recommendations by personal acquaintances and opinions posted by consumers online are the most trusted forms of advertising globally,” the Nielsen survey, the largest of its kind, shows that,  “nine in every ten Internet consumers worldwide (90 percent) trust recommendations from people they know, while seven in every ten (70 percent) trust consumer opinions posted online.”

This leads Trendwatching.com, in its September trend report to proclaim:

“Businesses have to understand and accept that consumers’ decision making processes, which ultimately come down to whether they will buy from you or from someone else, have truly shifted to a new, powerful peer-to-peer arena.”

While consumer-influenced purchasing via reviews and recommendations has been occurring online for some time, it certainly seems to be building to a feverish pitch. The very nature of social media encourages friends and acquaintances to freely share information and, therefore, to make opinions about products and services widely known. Trendwatching.com cites ShoutIT as an example of an application that allows consumers’ reviews to easily appear at once on Facebook, Digg, and Delicious pages.

Trendwatching points to a mind-boggling number of reviews floating around in the webosphere. Reviews are encouraged by online companies using consumer feedback as fodder for increasing repeat website visits.

Says Trendwatching: “Expect every industry, every sector, every product to eventually succumb to reviews.” In fact, think of Twitter as an example of a global real-time reviewing tool.

Perhaps the most curious sub-trend of the reviewing trend is the belief that reviews by ordinary, everyday people are just as trustworthy as reviews by supposed experts. While professional reviewers have their place, reviews written by friends, acquaintances, and “consumers whose lifestyles mirror yours” are regarded as relevant and real.

It’s all part of the transparency trend – consumers want to know all about companies and all about products. Increasingly, they demand the ability to instantly compare product benefits and prices online in an effort to get the best deal. The transparency trend means companies will have to be ever more sensitive to their competitors. They’ll also have to rapidly respond to bad reviews and do online damage control.

As Trendwatching says: “It’s ultimately about character, about finding your voice, about your behavior as a brand that, if in tune with the current zeitgeist of ‘openness’ and ‘generosity’, automatically turns transparency into a benefit instead of a threat.”

About Barry Silverstein

Barry Silverstein is a freelance writer/marketing consultant. In addition to writing for ReveNews, he is a contributing writer to Brandchannel.com, the world’s leading online branding forum. He is the author of three marketing books, The Breakaway Brand (co-author, McGraw-Hill, 2005), Business-to-Business Internet Marketing (Maximum Press, 2003) and Internet Marketing for Technology Companies (Maximum Press, 2003). Barry ran his own Internet and direct marketing agency for twenty years. You can find Barry on Twitter @bdsilv.

  • http://www.amnavigator.com/blog/2009/07/16/affiliates-and-merchants-stay-away-from-fake-reviews/ Stay Away from Fake

    Agreed, but it is also important to mention that both merchants and affiliates want to be careful, and stay away made-up "reviews" (cf: above link to my post on the topic).

  • http://www.bloggingwithchris.com Chris Peterson

    I really liked the research & quotes. It's a fabulous tool of endorsing your own ideas. However it ain't that simple & obvious to expect a willingness on part of corporates to be transparent & real. They can create that kinda impression faster than that & that's what is happening currently according to me, in certain cases. What do you think, Barry?

  • Barry Silverstein

    Chris, one of the big issues with reviewing is the way businesses react, or don't react, to it. The businesses that understand the power of the consumer react pretty quickly, as you said. Twitter in particular is a fast-action tool that some businesses use to quickly respond to a consumer's negative comment before it gets out of hand. Still, it is hard for a company to be completely open about itself. It usually takes a senior manager with support from the CEO to create a culture of trust and openness.

  • http://www.bloggingwithchris.com Chris Peterson

    Sure that people with higher authority have the power & access to tools to work on creating the culture of openness. I feel, it just becomes over ethical for them. What would be the line of demarcation in revealing the internal facts – product/service, profits, cautions, corporate identity, CSR?

  • Barry Silverstein

    Good question! Years ago there was a movement to open book management but that didn’t take off — probably because of competitive concerns. Companies will always have to keep some information close to the vest because of the competition. I think drawing the line is up to each individual business.

  • http://www.bloggingwithchris.com Chris Peterson

    Thanks Barry for all the reciprocation & time you have taken for giving detailed information. It is really valuable.

  • SPI

    This is a great topic, and I totally agree with you. I think customer reviews are great ways to learn about your company. Yes, you can get bad reviews that may be detrimental, but if you properly respond to these poor reviews you can find ways to improve your business. I have used twitter when deciding what movies to use and I'm a big fan of at least reading what people have to say about a business or service experience. A review might not always affect my decision, but I like to know what peoples' thoughts are.